Arms Warrior - What do you think?

[alucard001]

For PvP, what do you think of this?

http://www.wowprovider.com/?talent=1121 ... 5050104c5x

This is the best warrior's spec for pvp.

Also you can change Axe specialization for Sword. But i prefer to play with axe

[mike1097]

I think playing with an axe is better because of the amazing 10% crit

[Thrashing]

For PvP, what do you think of this?

http://www.wowprovider.com/?talent=1121 ... 5050104c5x

Overall it's good, but there's some choices I disagree with.

First of all, I would pick 2/5 in Deflection instead of Improved Heroic strike. You will rarely use Heroic Strike in PvP.
Second, I would drop Improved Charge and pick 2/3 Improved Hamstring instead. The increased rage gain isn't necessarily bad, but a 10% chance for a 5 second root can be extremely useful when peeling or going after a flag carrier.
Lastly, I would drop Unbridled Wrath in the Fury tree and swap those 5 points to Booming Voice. Unbridled Wrath won't have a gamechanging effect when using a 2-handed weapon. A 40% chance to gain 1 additional rage when using a 3.5 to 3.8 speed weapon (most likely) does not beat the increased area of effect on demoralizing shout which can be extremely useful to get Rogues out of stealth. A 3 minute duration Battleshout is also very useful in PvP because you won't find the time to rebuff it as often as you do in PvE.

Thus, you'd end up with the following spec:
http://www.wowprovider.com/?talent=1121 ... 5c0104005x


Edit: Regarding weapon choices:
Axe is, in my opinion, the best overall choice with the 5% extra crit.
Sword comes second, but is in my opinion generally more fun. It's a matter of taste, or a matter of who you face.
Mace comes third by a landslide. A random stun isn't something a Warrior is holding his breath for, especially since it can screw up the deminishing returns with charge and intercept.

[mike1097]

Thanks Trashing, I fully agree with you I will do it that way.

[showtime]

well 5% crit vs 5% extra attack

i think if you are lower on crit then 5% is a nice boost but if you have 24%crit or so i think sword could be better. crit doubles damage but sword proc has a chance to do another attack which is like 200% damage but at the same time that can also crit and do double damage so its better. sword proc seems like it could really make the difference in killing a healer easier

[Trolle]

Thanks Trashing, I fully agree with you I will do it that way.

I'd really listen to his advice, Thrashing really knows his warrior class. I don't know him personally but I've seen him on all private servers I've played on and he loves his arms pvping -_-

And I agree with all he says, even though I play Rogue I got plenty of understanding of melee as such, he is right on the money

[showtime]

Thanks Trashing, I fully agree with you I will do it that way.

I'd really listen to his advice, Thrashing really knows his warrior class. I don't know him personally but I've seen him on all private servers I've played on and he loves his arms pvping -_-

And I agree with all he says, even though I play Rogue I got plenty of understanding of melee as such, he is right on the money

na hes not really that good plus theres nothing impressive about warrior. get heal by friend and god mode

[Trolle]

Thanks Trashing, I fully agree with you I will do it that way.

I'd really listen to his advice, Thrashing really knows his warrior class. I don't know him personally but I've seen him on all private servers I've played on and he loves his arms pvping -_-

And I agree with all he says, even though I play Rogue I got plenty of understanding of melee as such, he is right on the money

na hes not really that good plus theres nothing impressive about warrior. get heal by friend and god mode

dps and heal is what it's all about, and yes he knows his class for pvp. Jesus that I even have to take this bait

[showtime]

all im saying is that theres nothing to playing warrior. ok i guess he knows his class but so does 80% of people who have been playing for more then catacylsm and above

hes not a god hes average warrior

[mike1097]

The point is, he discussed my question and gave me a good answer with reasons. I trust him. Thank you again